NO WIN, NO FEE*
Book A Consultation

Estate planning for blended families: why a simple Will may not be enough to protect your family

Reading time: 10 minutes

Leaving everything to your spouse or partner might seem like the best way to provide for your loved ones. But in a blended family, could that decision unintentionally leave children from a previous relationship without an inheritance? Legal Practice Director Jeff Garrett explains the risks of relying on a simple Will and how careful estate planning can help balance the needs of your partner and children.

The Brady Bunch is arguably television’s most famous blended family. A husband and wife, each with three children from a previous marriage, bringing two households together under one roof.

Throughout the series and its many spin-offs, viewers watched the family navigate the awkward adjustments, sibling rivalries and occasional tensions that came with their new family dynamic. But the show never explored what can happen to the family’s assets if one spouse dies.

If Mike Brady had died, would Carol have made sure Greg, Peter and Bobby received their share of his estate? Well, in the PG-rated world of The Brady Bunch, Carol probably would have. In the real world, these situations can be far more complex and contentious.

With one-third of Australian marriages and de facto partnerships forming as second marriages or de facto relationships, often with children from a previous relationship, blended families have become a common part of modern life. And while bringing two families together can be rewarding, it can also create complicated questions about inheritance, particularly when it comes to balancing the needs of a surviving partner with those of children from a previous relationship.

What can happen when one spouse dies

The scenario that causes the most problems involves couples who have been together for many years. Both are on their second marriage or serious relationship, both have adult children from earlier relationships, and they now have grandchildren as well. The spouses naturally want to look after each other, and they want the partner left behind to live comfortably on the assets they built together.

The difficulty arises after the first death, particularly where the children and the stepparent have never been close. In some families, children are at the door the day after a parent’s death, asking where their half share of the house is. Where relationships were already strained, elder abuse, financial abuse and threats can follow.

Another scenario is just as common. Couples often agree that when both have died, their assets will be divided equally between each side’s children. Yet, the surviving spouse changes their Will within days of the other’s death. Unless the couple has put safeguards in place, nothing legally prevents them from doing so.

Couples sometimes dismiss these risks because they trust their partner and their children. But a lot can change after death. The partner left behind may re-partner, family relationships may break down, and the surviving spouse may decide to leave everything to their own side of the family.

A child from the second relationship adds another layer of complexity, because the couple now has a much younger child to provide for alongside adult children from earlier relationships.

The practical aim is to protect the “notional half share” of the assets intended for your own side of the family. It is notional because most of those assets are jointly owned. A proper estate plan considers your unique family makeup and addresses every asset, including non-estate assets, how they are owned, and who receives them.

Jointly owned assets fall outside of your Will

Couples in a blended family who buy a home together will likely hold it as joint tenants. For most, the family home is their largest asset. On death, a joint tenant’s share automatically passes to the surviving owner. It makes no difference if your Will leaves your share to your children from a previous relationship, because you can’t gift jointly owned assets in a Will.

Other assets that fall outside of the estate and cannot be gifted in a Will include:


Each of these needs to be dealt with separately as part of the estate planning process.

Strategies for blended families can include severing a joint tenancy, creating a testamentary trust, or in limited circumstances, making mutual Wills.

Read more: Jointly owned assets and estate planning

Which Will best suits a blended family?

The Simple Will

A Simple Will is unsuitable for most blended families. It usually leaves the whole estate to a spouse or partner, or if there is none, splits the estate equally between the children. It nominates an executor and a small number of beneficiaries, and can name guardians for minor children and record funeral wishes.

This suits a typical nuclear family. But in a blended family, it relies entirely on the survivor to carry out your wishes in the future. If you leave everything to your partner expecting your children to receive their share later, your partner can change their own Will after you have passed away, and leave everything to their own children.

The Mutual Will

A mutual Will is a contractual Will. Both parties agree not to change their Will after the other dies so that the survivor can use the assets for their lifetime, after which they pass to the children in the agreed proportions.

Mutual Wills are recognised in Australia, but their enforceability remains uncertain. Many court cases deal with problems that arise from them. Circumstances also change over the years in ways the original agreement may not anticipate. For these reasons, many experienced estate planning lawyers advise against them and recommend other strategies.

Read more: What are “Mutual Wills”?

Reciprocal Wills

Mutual Wills and reciprocal Wills often get confused. Reciprocal Wills are made separately but contain matching provisions, with each spouse leaving everything to the other and then to the children. There is no contract between the partners, which means the survivor can change their Will at any time after their partner passes away if they choose to do so.

Testamentary Trust Wills

A Testamentary Trust Will is a more complex document that lets the testator establish a trust from their estate, with the trust’s terms set out in the Will. In a blended family, this arrangement can isolate certain assets and appoint an independent trustee to distribute them to beneficiaries.

Read more: Keeping your hard-won assets in the family – family trusts and ensuring assets transfer to the next generation

Severing a joint tenancy

The alternative most often recommended is to sever any joint tenancy, so the couple instead own the family home as tenants in common in equal shares. Each spouse can then deal with their share of the property in their own Wills.

From there, there are two common options:

  • A life interest on trust: Your half share is left on trust for your spouse for their lifetime, then returns to your estate and passes to your children. Appoint a co-trustee alongside the surviving spouse to ensure the terms of the trust are honoured. This approach can apply to most other assets as well.
  • A right of occupation: The Will gives the surviving spouse the right to remain in the family home for life. When that right ends, the deceased’s share passes to the intended beneficiaries.


This approach is more involved and more expensive than a Simple Will, but it guarantees that the surviving spouse is looked after and that your agreed share reaches your side of the family.

Keep it up to date

Life events should always trigger a review of your estate plan, including marriage, divorce, and the birth of a child. Marriage and divorce can themselves change the effect of a Will.

If you made a Will and did not update it after separating from your partner, your former partner could inherit if you suddenly pass away. If you appointed an ex as your attorney under an Enduring Power of Attorney, and did not revoke it, they could control your finances and make personal and health-related decisions for you if you lose mental capacity.

People who have re-partnered without finalising the end of an earlier marriage face additional risks. Until a divorce is granted, the law still treats that person as your spouse. Unresolved property matters become much harder to untangle if one person dies in the middle of the process. In these cases, you may need advice from both an estate planning lawyer and a family lawyer.

Review your Will and other estate planning documents at least every three years, or whenever something significant changes in your life.

Attwood Marshall Lawyers – helping you plan for the future and preserve your wishes

Most clients begin with the same request: “I just want a simple Will.” In a blended family, the circumstances are almost always more complicated than you expect. An experienced estate planning lawyer can walk you through the issues, explain the likely costs before you sign up and let you decide how to proceed.

Attwood Marshall Lawyers has a dedicated team that practices exclusively in succession law and estate planning.

To understand what documents you may need for your estate plan, contact our Wills and Estates Department Manager Donna Tolley on direct line 07 5506 8241, email dtolley@attwoodmarshall.com.au, or free call 1800 621 071.

You can also make an appointment with our estate planning lawyers online via our booking app. We can meet with clients at any of our conveniently located offices at Coolangatta, Robina Town Centre, Southport, Kingscliff, Brisbane, Sydney, and Melbourne.

FAQs

Only if the property is not held as joint tenants. A joint tenant’s share passes automatically to the surviving owner, so the tenancy usually needs to be severed first so each owner holds a share they can leave in their Will.

Yes, unless the two of you have made a binding contractual arrangement such as a mutual Will. With Simple Wills and reciprocal Wills, the survivor is free to change their Will at any time.

Mutual Wills are recognised, but their enforceability is uncertain, and many court cases deal with disputes about them. Many experienced estate planning lawyers recommend other strategies.

In the eyes of the law, you remain married until the divorce is finalised. Unless your Will and other documents have been updated, your estranged spouse could benefit from your estate, from jointly owned assets, and possibly from superannuation or life insurance.

You do not legally need a lawyer to make a Will, but professional advice is particularly important for blended families.

Verbal wishes and home-made Wills do not adequately protect your partner or children. An experienced estate planning lawyer can help you understand how your assets will be distributed, identify potential inheritance disputes, and put the right arrangements in place to protect your loved ones and ensure your wishes are carried out as intended.

Share this article

Jeff Garrett - Legal Practice Director - Wills & Estates, Estate Litigation, Property & Commercial, Compensation Law, Commercial Litigation, Criminal Law, Racing & Equine Law

Jeff Garrett

Legal Practice Director
Commercial Litigation, Compensation Law, Criminal Law, Estate Litigation, Property & Commercial, Racing & Equine Law, Wills & Estates

Contact the author

Disclaimer
The contents of this article are considered accurate as at the date of publication. The information contained in this article does not constitute legal advice and is of a general nature only. Readers should seek legal advice about their specific circumstances. 

Brisbane Employment Law

Employment Law Sydney

Gold Coast Employment Law

Defamation Law

Employment Law

Download a Brochure

Please enter your details below and
a link will be emailed to you
Download Form

Compensation Law

Select your state