Family Law Associate Breanna Farrell explains how the law views deceitful behaviour when negotiating a property settlement after separation, and what can happen if one party tries to hide or diminish their assets.
A relationship breakdown is rarely simple or serene. Dividing finances and assets is one of the most challenging aspects of a separation, especially when one person isn’t fully upfront about what they own or earn.
From undisclosed bank accounts to cryptocurrency and hidden income, these situations can make an already stressful process even more complicated.
Property settlements are one of the most difficult and emotive issues separated couples fight over. It is not uncommon for people to be concerned about whether a former partner will be deceitful and to try and conceal assets, including income, superannuation, business assets, or property, during a separation to reduce what their ex-partner might receive in the settlement.
Thankfully, our family law rules and legislation make it really clear for litigants: parties to family law property matters have a duty to provide and exchange full and frank financial disclosure.
Our family courts do not entertain parties who wilfully disregard this duty or purposely hide assets. Our family courts have the power to grant leave to a requesting party to issue subpoenas, compelling disclosure and potentially make costs orders against those who continually disregard orders for disclosure.
This positive duty is there to ensure parties can make informed decisions about the division of their assets in the fairest and most reasonable way. There are ways to uncover if someone is not being completely upfront and honest with what they earn and what they own.
The duty to disclose everything
When parties negotiate a property settlement, both must disclose all assets and liabilities, including those jointly owned, individually owned or held within a company.
Each party needs to provide:
- Information about any trusts that they have an interest in,
- Tax returns,
- Payslips,
- Evidence of assets sold or disposed of near the end of the relationship or during separation,
- Superannuation statements,
- Bank statements for all accounts held,
- Documents relating to any inheritances received, and
- And any other documents or information that may be relevant, including liabilities or short-term loans like Afterpay and Zip Pay.
How hard is it for someone to hide assets in disclosure during divorce?
The overarching message is that it is better to over-disclose your assets, liabilities and financial position, rather than under-disclose and get caught out.
But it’s no surprise that when couples separate with animosity, one party might try to conceal their assets. As a family lawyer, I’ve seen many creative ways people try to hide their assets, including withdrawing small amounts of cash regularly, which can accumulate overtime into a significant sum, or withdrawing large amounts and claiming they lost it gambling.
Some other ways a party might attempt to conceal an asset include:
- Moving money between a multitude of bank accounts,
- Investing in a new business venture,
- Investing in cryptocurrency thinking that the investment cannot be traced, or
- Overpaying bills in attempt to hide money and deplete bank accounts.
- Over purchasing of ‘gift cards.’
An experienced family lawyer can identify these things and ensure all assets that form part of the property pool are adequately identified.
Modern assets like cryptocurrency or online investment accounts can be easier to trace or subpoena than people might think. A financial tracing exercise can reveal those transactions and follow where that money is going.
If the matter is already before the court and litigation has commenced, subpoenas can be issued to uncover hidden bank accounts or other assets that a party has not disclosed.
In April 2022, the Government also introduced new measures to improve transparency in property settlements as far as superannuation is concerned.
The laws are designed to ensure fairness in property settlements to prevent under-reporting of superannuation assets, and they enable a secure electronic information-sharing mechanism between the Family Law courts and the Australian Tax Office. This means the court can see superannuation information held by the ATO, so these assets cannot be concealed as easily.
Disclosure during divorce: negotiating a property settlement
When a married or de facto couple separates, a five-step test determines each person’s entitlement at settlement.
The property division test follows these steps:
Step 1: Determine whether it is just and equitable to adjust the parties’ interests in property. If it is found that an adjustment would be just and equitable, then you will proceed to the next step.
Step 2: Determine what property each party holds and what the property’s value is. This includes all assets such as bank accounts, superannuation, houses, motor vehicles, insurance policies, household items, etc.
Step 3: Consideration will be given to the contributions made by both parties, both financial and non-financial, during the relationship. Financial contributions include income and property interests. Non-financial contributions include unpaid work such as renovations or work for a family company. Homemaking duties and parenting are also factored in.
Step 4: The courts will assess both parties’ future needs. Several factors help determine someone’s future needs, including age, health status, income earning capacity, and any commitments either party has to support themselves or a dependent, among other considerations.
Step 5: Taking into account the above steps, a court must determine whether it has arrived at a just and equitable division of assets. A court may determine that further adjustments are required, or it may proceed with orders to end the parties’ financial relationship.
Consequences if someone attempts to conceal assets during a property settlement
The courts do not take kindly to parties who deliberately fail to disclose or adhere to their duties. This falls under the umbrella of fundamental dishonesty. The court may infer what assets a party has or doesn’t have based on their non-disclosure, which can significantly affect the overall adjustment.
There are also mechanisms in place throughout the litigation process – for example, if a party has gone to the expense of having to issue subpoenas, they might seek costs to cover that.
Penalties have toughened in recent years as the courts try to crack down on parties hiding assets during separation. Anyone who fails to provide “full and frank” disclosure in family law proceedings can be charged with contempt, and this can result in a significant fine or even imprisonment.
Steps to take early
Before you initiate proceedings, it’s important to ask questions. Ask your accountant questions to really understand your financial position. If you are a joint signatory or you are also named on a bank account, you can go directly to that bank and ask for copies of statements. Even if you don’t have access to the organisation’s app or online accounts, you can take steps to understand what you and your spouse have purchased throughout the relationship.
A common misconception is that after separation, any financial decisions or investments you make will not be factored into a property settlement. This is not true. You must disclose financial information that is relevant up to the point that the property settlement is finalised.
You have only 12 months from the date your divorce takes effect to settle property matters or apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for orders.
De facto couples have two years from the date of separation to settle property matters.
These deadlines are one of the main reasons why it is recommended to settle property matters as soon as possible when a relationship breaks down. You don’t need to be divorced to finalise a property settlement. Acting on a property settlement immediately allows all parties to move on independently, without ongoing ramifications for future financial decisions.
Attwood Marshall Lawyers – supporting families through separation and resolving disputes with as little conflict as possible
When a relationship ends, get trusted legal advice as soon as possible to understand how to protect your interests. An experienced family lawyer can help you formalise an agreement that everyone is comfortable with, that is fair and reasonable.
Attwood Marshall Lawyers has a dedicated team of family solicitors who practice exclusively in this complex area of law. Our team can help with all aspects of family law, including negotiating property settlements, divorce applications, binding financial agreements, parenting arrangements, child support and spousal maintenance.
To book an appointment with one of our lawyers, please contact our Family Law Department Manager, Donna Tolley, on direct line 07 5506 8241, email dtolley@attwoodmarshall.com.au or free call our 24/7 phone line on 1800 621 071.
