Attwood Marshall Lawyers Partner and Accredited Aged Care Professional Debbie Sage looks at how ageism can undermine an older person’s right to make their own decisions, and what health and aged care professionals can do to keep that right front and centre.
Negative stereotypes about ageing can increase social isolation, reduce access to justice and normalise disrespectful behaviour toward older people.
Under Australian law, every adult is presumed to have the capacity to make their own decisions unless there is clear evidence to the contrary. Yet in practice, people often apply the exact opposite standard – wrongly assuming that simply because someone is an older person, they lack capacity to make their own decisions.
Recognising this gap between the law and everyday practice is the first step toward better supporting older people.
Australian Human Rights Commission research has described ageism as “one of the most pervasive and tolerated forms of prejudice in Australia”, while also noting that it is one of the easiest attitudes to shift.
Here, we stress the importance of dignity, autonomy and supported decision-making, and discuss how aged care professionals can play a role in ensuring older people are active participants in decision-making rather than passive recipients of support.
Ageism and the presumption of capacity
Growing older does not make a person less entitled to independence, privacy or control over their assets. Nor does a diagnosis of dementia, Parkinson’s disease or other health conditions automatically mean that a person cannot make decisions for themselves.
Ageism can be more subtle than overt discrimination. It occurs when people make assumptions, or adopt attitudes, policies or behaviours, that treat people differently because of their age. For example, assuming an older person is forgetful, frail, lonely or unable to make a decision; dismissing an older person’s concerns by saying “that’s just part of getting older”; or making decisions on behalf of an older person without seeking their views.
In practice, ageism most often affects older people through the way capacity is assessed and how decisions are made around them.
Capacity is one of the most misunderstood concepts in ageing. Age alone does not establish incapacity.
Capacity is also decision-specific rather than all-or-nothing. A person may manage everyday decisions about food, clothing or where they want to live without difficulty, while needing support with a complex financial or legal transaction. It can fluctuate as well. Someone living with a cognitive impairment may be alert and able to engage clearly with a decision in the morning, then find the same conversation more difficult later in the day.
Generally, the relevant question is whether the person can understand the particular decision in front of them, weigh up its consequences and communicate a choice at the time that decision needs to be made.
When an older client decides something that a professional does not understand or agree with, the instinct is sometimes to question their capacity. But a more appropriate starting point would be to question the decision and ask what considerations were taken into account to reach that decision. It is also worth considering what other pressures might be evident that may be shaping that decision and how those pressures can be reduced in order to preserve the person’s autonomy.
Jumping to a conclusion of incapacity without going through the proper processes and assessments risks handing decision-making authority to someone else without a proper lawful basis.
Where family members or representatives step in to manage an older person’s affairs without proper authority, or act beyond the scope of a valid Enduring Power of Attorney, they may be acting outside their legal rights, even where they may have good intentions.
The older person’s preferences should remain central. Their money and other assets should not be used for someone else’s benefit without lawful authority and/or free, informed consent.
The dignity of risk
Closely tied to capacity is the concept of dignity of risk. This is the idea that a person who has capacity is entitled to make choices that involve risk, even where others may choose differently.
For example, an older person may decide to take an expensive holiday, buy a new car or make a significant gift to a cause they care about.
Provided they understand the decision and its likely consequences, the fact that it is risky, or might reduce a future inheritance, does not make it improper.
Guidance from the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission recognises dignity of risk as part of supporting choice, independence and quality of life. Staff, family and carers may disagree with a decision, but that does not mean they can make the decision on the person’s behalf. An older person has the right to make choices, including choices that involve personal risk, in the same way any other adult does.
The Aged Care Act 2024, which commenced on 1 November 2025, reinforces this through its Statement of Rights, which confirms that older people are entitled to make their own decisions, have those decisions respected, and receive the information and support needed to exercise that right. The Act places corresponding obligations on aged care providers and workers to uphold these rights in practice.
Practical steps for professionals
Presume capacity
Include the older person in every discussion concerning their life, care and property where possible and speak directly to them rather than only to relatives or their support person.
Do not assume incapacity because of age, disability or diagnosis. Where a specific decision is complex, consider whether communication support or a formal capacity assessment for that decision is appropriate, rather than treating the person as generally incapable.
Respect the person’s choices
Take the time to understand what matters to the individual and respect their right to spend their own money on their own care, comfort and enjoyment. A decision is not invalid simply because family members disagree with it.
Create opportunities for private discussion
Wherever possible, give the older person a chance to speak privately with relevant health, financial and legal professionals – separate from their family members. This can help identify pressure, fear or undue influence that might not surface in a group setting.
Attwood Marshall Lawyers – supporting older Australians and the professionals who work with them
Recognising and addressing ageism is an ongoing responsibility for everyone who works with older people, from health practitioners and aged care staff through to financial institutions and legal advisers. Upholding the presumption of capacity protects not only an individual’s legal rights, but their dignity, autonomy and place at the centre of decisions about their own life.
Attwood Marshall Lawyers has an experienced Aged Care team that works alongside health, care and financial professionals to support older clients through capacity-related matters, Enduring Powers of Attorney and broader aged care planning.
To find out more about our services, please contact our Aged Care and Wills and Estates Department Manager, Donna Tolley, on direct line 07 5506 8241, email dtolley@attwoodmarshall.com.au or free call 1800 621 071.
